[1]漆国栋,文化,漆伟,等.手术与非手术治疗肱骨干骨折安全性的Meta分析[J].中医正骨,2021,33(08):33-38.
　QI Guodong,WEN Hua,QI Wei,et al.Comparison of the safety of surgical treatment versus nonsurgical treatment for humeral shaft fractures:a meta-analysis[J].The Journal of Traditional Chinese Orthopedics and Traumatology,2021,33(08):33-38.
点击复制

手术与非手术治疗肱骨干骨折安全性的Meta分析()
分享到：

《中医正骨》[ISSN:1001-6015/CN:41-1162/R]

卷:
第33卷
期数:
2021年08期
页码:
33-38
栏目:
文献研究
出版日期:
2021-08-20

文章信息/Info

Title:
Comparison of the safety of surgical treatment versus nonsurgical treatment for humeral shaft fractures:a meta-analysis
作者:
漆国栋1; 文化1; 漆伟1; 江琼2; 张雪2; 李姝君2
(1.重庆市中医骨科医院,重庆 400010; 2.重庆医科大学中医药学院,重庆 400016)
Author(s):
QI Guodong1; WEN Hua1; QI Wei1; JIANG Qiong2; ZHANG Xue2; LI Shujun2
1.Chongqing Orthopaedic Hospital of Traditional Chinese medicine,Chongqing 400010,China2.College of Traditional Chinese Medicine.CQMU,Chongqing 400016,China
关键词:
肱骨骨折;  手术中并发症;  手术后并发症;  外科手术;  非手术治疗;  Meta分析;  系统评价
Keywords:
humeral fractures;  intraoperative complications;  postoperative complications;  surgical procedures; operative;  non-surgical treatment;  meta analysis;  systematic review
摘要:
目的:比较手术与非手术治疗肱骨干骨折的安全性。方法:应用计算机检索PubMed、EMbase、Cochrane Library、中国知网、万方数据库和维普网2011年1月至2021年1月收录的对比手术和非手术治疗肱骨干骨折的临床研究文献。由2名研究者根据纳入、排除标准及统一的文献信息提取表独立检索、筛选文献并提取数据,采用ROBINS-I和Cochrane偏倚风险评估工具对纳入文献的质量进行评估,采用RevMan5.3软件进行Meta分析。结果:共检索出658篇文献,最终纳入9篇文献,共涉及1513例肱骨干骨折患者,其中889例接受手术治疗、624例接受非手术治疗。Meta分析结果显示,手术组骨折不愈合率、骨折畸形愈合率、皮肤不良反应率均低于非手术组[I2=28%,P=0.230,OR=0.32,95%CI(0.19,0.54); I2=0%,P=0.470,OR=0.06,95%CI(0.01,0.23); I2=0%,P=0.950,OR=0.09,95%CI(0.02,0.49)],手术组骨折延迟愈合率、医源性神经损伤率、手术部位感染率均高于非手术组[I2=44%,P=0.150,OR=1.64,95%CI(0.94,2.86); I2=0%,P=0.940,OR=4.75,95%CI(1.55,14.57); I2=0%,P=0.930,OR=3.63,95%CI(0.93,14.17)]。结论:现有的证据表明,相较于非手术治疗,手术治疗肱骨干骨折的骨折不愈合率、畸形愈合率和皮肤不良反应率均较低,而骨折延迟愈合率、医源性神经损伤率和手术部位感染率均较高。
Abstract:
Objective:To compare the safety of surgical treatment versus nonsurgical treatment for humeral shaft fractures.Methods:All articles concerning surgical treatment(surgical group)versus nonsurgical treatment(non-surgical group)for humeral shaft fractures that published at home and abroad included from January 2011 to January 2021 were retrieved from PubMed,EMbase,Cochrane Library,China National Knowledge Internet,WanFang Database and VIP Database through computer.The articles were retrieved and screened and the information was extracted independently by two researchers according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria as well as unified literature information extraction table.The methodological quality of research in the articles was evaluated by using ROBINS-Iand Cochrane bias risk assessment tools and a Meta-analysis was conducted by using RevMan 5.3 software.Results:Six hundred and fifty-eight articles were searched out.After screening,9 articles(1513 patients)were included in the final analysis,889 patients in surgical group and 624 patients in nonsurgical group.The results of Meta-analysis revealed that the fracture nonunion rate,fracture malunion rate and skin adverse reaction rate were lower in surgical group compared to nonsurgical group(I2=28%,P=0.230,OR=0.32,95%CI(0.19,0.54); I2=0%,P=0.470,OR=0.06,95%CI(0.01,0.23); I2=0%,P=0.950,OR=0.09,95%CI(0.02,0.49)); while the fracture delayed union rate,iatrogenic nerve injury rate and surgical site infection rate were higher in surgical group compared to nonsurgical group(I2=44%,P=0.150,OR=1.64,95%CI(0.94,2.86); I2=0%,P=0.940,OR=4.75,95%CI(1.55,14.57); I2=0%,P=0.930,OR=3.63,95%CI(0.93,14.17)).Conclusion:Available evidences suggest that the fracture nonunion rate,fracture malunion rate and skin adverse reaction rate are lower,whereas the fracture delayed union rate,iatrogenic nerve injury rate and surgical site infection rate are higher in patients undergoing surgical treatment compared to nonsurgical treatment for humeral shaft fractures.

参考文献/References:

[1] LI Y,NING G,WU Q,et al.Review of literature of radial nerve injuries associated with humeral fractures-an integrated management strategy[J]. PLoS One,2013,8(11):e78576.
[2] BERGDAHL C,EKHOLM C,WENNERGREN D,et al.Epidemiology and patho-anatomical pattern of 2,011 humeral fractures:data from the Swedish Fracture Register[J].BMC Musculoskelet Disord,2016,17:159.
[3] EKHOLM R,PONZER S,T?NKVIST H,et al.The Holstein-Lewis humeral shaft fracture:aspects of radial nerve injury,primary treatment,and outcome[J].J Orthop Trauma,2008,22(10):693-697.
[4] TOIVANEN J A,NIEMINEN J,LAINE H J,et al.Functional treatment of closed humeral shaft fractures[J].Int Orthop,2005,29(1):10-13.
[5] TETSWORTH K,HOHMANN E,GLATT V.Minimally invasive plate osteosynthesis of humeral shaft fractures:current state of the art[J].J Am Acad Orthop Surg,2018,26(18):652-661.
[6] UPDEGROVE G F,MOURAD W,ABBOUD J A.Humeral shaft fractures[J].J Shoulder Elbow Surg,2018,27(4):e87-e97.
[7] STERNE J A,HERNáN M A,REEVES B C,et al.ROBINS-I:a tool for assessing risk of bias in non-randomised studies of interventions[J].BMJ,2016,355:i4919.
[8] HIGGINS J P,ALTMAN D G,G?TZSCHE P C,et al.The Cochrane Collaboration’s tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials[J].BMJ,2011,343:d5928.
[9] VAN MIDDENDORP J J,KAZACSAY F,LICHTENHAHN P,et al.Outcomes following operative and non-operative management of humeral midshaft fractures:a prospective,observational cohort study of 47 patients[J].Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg,2011,37(3):287-296.
[10] FIRAT A,DEVECI A,GüLER F,et al.Evaluation of shoulder and elbow functions after treatment of humeral shaft fractures:a 20-132-month follow-up study[J].Acta Orthop Traumatol Turc,2012,46(4):229-236.
[11] MAHABIER K C,VOGELS L M,PUNT B J,et al.Humeral shaft fractures:retrospective results of non-operative and operative treatment of 186 patients[J].Injury,2013,44(4):427-430.
[12] 刘西纺,武全民,柯军宝,等.四动五步法与切开复位内固定治疗闭合性肱骨干骨折疗效比较[J].中国骨与关节损伤杂志,2016,31(3):267-269.
[13] WESTRICK E,HAMILTON B,TOOGOOD P,et al.Humeral shaft fractures:results of operative and non-operative treatment[J]. Int Orthop,2017,41(2):385-395.
[14] MATSUNAGA F T,TAMAOKI M J,MATSUMOTO M H,et al.Minimally invasive osteosynthesis with a bridge plate versus a functional brace for humeral shaft fractures: a randomized controlled trial[J]. J Bone Joint Surg Am,2017,99(7):583-592.
[15] HARKIN F E,LARGE R J.Humeral shaft fractures:union outcomes in a large cohort[J].J Shoulder Elbow Surg,2017,26(11):1881-1888.
[16] DIELWART C,HARMER L,THOMPSON J,et al.Management of closed diaphyseal humerus fractures in patients with injury severity score≥17[J].J Orthop Trauma,2017,31(4):220-224.
[17] 张伯松,李文毅,刘兴华,等.肱骨干骨折手术与非手术治疗的比较[J].北京大学学报(医学版),2017,49(5):851-854.
[18] KEHTARI S,GALLUSSER N,VAUCLAIR F.Update on humeral shaft fractures[J].Rev Med Suisse,2020,16(719):2421-2425.
[19] SCHITTKO A.Humeral shaft fractures[J].Chirurg,2004,75(8):833-846.
[20] 王亦璁,姜保国.骨与关节损伤[M].5版.北京:人民卫生出版社,2011:777.
[21] OLIVER W M,SMITH T J,NICHOLSON J A,et al.The Radiographic Union Score for Humeral fractures(RUSHU)predicts humeral shaft nonunion[J].Bone Joint J,2019,101-B(10):1300-1306.
[22] STREUFERT B D,EAFORD I,SELLERS T R,et al.Iatrogenic nerve palsy occurs with anterior and posterior approaches for humeral shaft fixation[J].J Orthop Trauma,2020,34(3):163-168.
[23] LIU G D,ZHANG Q G,OU S,et al.Meta-analysis of the outcomes of intramedullary nailing and plate fixation of humeral shaft fractures[J].Int J Surg,2013,11(9):864-868.
[24] SPIGUEL A R,STEFFNER R J.Humeral shaft fractures[J].Curr Rev Musculoskelet Med,2012,5(3):177-183.
[25] CRESPO A M,KONDA S R,EGOL K A.Set it and Forget it:diaphyseal fractures of the humerus undergo minimal change in angulation after functional brace application[J].Iowa Orthop J,2018,38:73-77.
[26] SHIELDS E,SUNDEM L,CHILDS S,et al.The impact of residual angulation on patient reported functional outcome scores after non-operative treatment for humeral shaft fractures[J].Injury,2016,47(4):914-918.
[27] 王广伟,霍力为,贺华勇,等.手法复位小夹板外固定配合垂直悬吊治疗肱骨干中上段不稳定骨折[J].中医正骨,2019,31(3):63-65.
[28] 陈元荣,江湧,邓蕴源,等.手法复位小夹板固定治疗肱骨干中下段粉碎性骨折[J].中医正骨,2019,31(3):66-69.

相似文献/References:

[1]朱峰,宋相建,吴蔚,等.手法复位经皮克氏针内固定治疗 儿童闭合性肱骨远端全骨骺分离[J].中医正骨,2015,27(11):51.
[2]沈海,刘昕,彭玉兰,等.复位架牵引下手法复位经皮穿针内固定治疗 儿童肱骨髁上骨折的临床研究[J].中医正骨,2015,27(10):1.
　SHEN Hai,LIU Xin,PENG Yulan,et al.Clinical study on reduction frame traction combined with manipulative reduction and percutaneous Kirschner wire internal fixation for treatment of humeral supracondylar fractures in children[J].The Journal of Traditional Chinese Orthopedics and Traumatology,2015,27(08):1.
[3]钱平康,徐锋,孙斌峰,等.肱骨近端内锁定系统固定结合植骨治疗肱骨近端骨折[J].中医正骨,2015,27(09):36.
[4]姜自伟,欧阳崇志,黄枫,等.肱骨近端骨折改良Neer分型的四部评分法[J].中医正骨,2015,27(09):64.
[5]余斌峰,王伟良,林锡鹏.加长型肱骨近端内固定锁定系统治疗肱骨干骨折 合并同侧肱骨近端骨折[J].中医正骨,2015,27(08):23.
[6]黄杨,王昌兴,邹阳.AO钛制弹性髓内钉内固定与切开复位钢板内固定治疗 小儿肱骨干中下段骨折的比较研究[J].中医正骨,2015,27(07):22.
　HUNAG Yang,WANG Changxing,ZOU Yang.A comparative study of AO titanium elastic stable intramedullary nail internal fixation versus open reduction plate osteosynthesis for the treatment of mid-distal humeral fractures in children[J].The Journal of Traditional Chinese Orthopedics and Traumatology,2015,27(08):22.
[7]刘昕,邓志强,叶家军.大龄儿童肱骨外髁陈旧性骨折不愈合继发肘外翻畸形的 分期手术治疗[J].中医正骨,2015,27(07):55.
[8]江涛,江林,史俊德.逆转推压法复位克氏针内固定治疗小儿肱骨外髁Ⅲ型骨折[J].中医正骨,2015,27(12):60.
[9]王海敏,汤志刚,诸葛天瑜,等.桥接组合式内固定系统固定治疗肱骨远端骨折[J].中医正骨,2015,27(12):63.
[10]蒋健,杨晓.尺侧小切口复位结合经皮交叉克氏针内固定 治疗儿童肱骨髁上骨折[J].中医正骨,2015,27(02):60.

备注/Memo

备注/Memo:
基金项目:重庆市科卫联合中医药技术创新与应用发展项目(2021ZY023901); 重庆市名老中医药专家传承工作室建设项目(渝中医〔2020〕20号17)
通讯作者:漆伟 E-mail:qiwei200@126.com
更新日期/Last Update: 1900-01-01